Expert Witness
Nov 15, 2026

RICS Opens Consultation on a New Conflicts of Interest and Confidentiality Standard: What the 'Reasonable Third Party' Test and New AI Rules Mean for Surveyors Acting as Expert Witnesses (November 2026)

RICS is consulting (5 November 2026 to 27 January 2027) on a second edition of its Conflicts of interest and confidentiality standard, adding a third-party test and AI rules. What surveyor expert witnesses and instructing solicitors should do now.

Two RICS deadlines now sit a few weeks apart, and together they will reshape how a surveyor decides whether to accept an expert witness instruction at all. On 30 November 2026 the fifth edition of Surveyors acting as expert witnesses takes effect [3]. Five days earlier, on 5 November 2026, RICS opened a consultation on a second edition of its Conflicts of interest and confidentiality standard, which closes at 23:59 on 27 January 2027 [1]. For any RICS conflicts of interest expert witness surveyor question, that second document will soon be the rulebook, and it introduces two ideas that matter enormously in litigation: a "reasonable and informed third party" perspective on conflicts, and new provisions on artificial intelligence [1].

Key Takeaways

  • RICS is consulting on Conflicts of interest and confidentiality, Global, 2nd Edition from 5 November 2026 to 27 January 2027, with responses by comment, questionnaire or uploaded document [1].
  • The draft strengthens requirements for identifying, assessing, managing, recording and monitoring conflicts, with more emphasis on informed consent, governance, record-keeping and confidential information [1].
  • Two new areas are added: third-party perceptions of conflicts and artificial intelligence [1].
  • For expert witnesses, the "reasonable and informed third party" test echoes the way courts already look at an expert's independence under CPR Part 35 [4].
  • The new standard will sit alongside the 5th edition expert witness standard that applies from 30 November 2026, so conflict checks and AI disclosure need building into instruction procedures now [3].

What RICS has published and when the consultation closes

The consultation runs on RICS's iConsult platform. It opened on 5 November 2026 and closes at 23:59 on 27 January 2027. Members and other stakeholders can respond in three ways: by commenting on the consultation document itself, by completing an online questionnaire, or by uploading a response document [1].

RICS explains the background. The first edition of Conflicts of interest was published as a professional statement in March 2017. In July 2023 it was reissued as a professional standard, a reclassification that did not change the regulatory requirements. The update is intended to support compliance with the current RICS Rules of Conduct, and in particular Rule 1, the duty to act with integrity [1].

The Rules of Conduct already place a clear obligation on members and regulated firms: they must not provide advice or services where a conflict exists, or where there is a significant risk of one, unless it is handled in line with the Conflicts of interest professional standard [1]. The second edition is about how that handling is done and recorded.

What is changing in the second edition

In RICS's words, the second edition "clarifies and strengthens requirements for identifying, assessing, managing, recording and monitoring conflicts of interest". It places greater emphasis on informed consent, governance, record-keeping, compliance and the protection of confidential information [1].

The two genuinely new areas are:

  • Third-party perceptions of conflicts, using a "reasonable and informed third-party perspective" when assessing whether a conflict exists [1].
  • Artificial intelligence, which did not feature in the 2017 text at all [1].

The draft was developed with an expert group of professionals from a range of sectors and jurisdictions, together with representatives of the legal profession. RICS says it wants feedback to ensure the requirements are clear, proportionate and practical across different sectors, firm sizes and jurisdictions [1].

RICS's Standards and Regulation Board had signalled this work in its Q3 update of 10 September 2026, which flagged an autumn consultation on conflicts covering identification, informed consent, confidentiality, governance, record-keeping, third-party perceptions and AI [2].

Why conflicts matter more for a RICS conflicts of interest expert witness surveyor than for any other role

Most surveying work involves one client. Expert witness work involves a client, an opposing party, and a court or tribunal to which the expert owes an overriding duty. Under CPR Part 35 that duty to help the court on matters within the expert's expertise overrides any obligation to the person instructing or paying the expert [4].

A conflict that might be managed with disclosure and consent in a valuation instruction can be fatal in litigation. If an expert has a connection to one party that a reasonable observer would think could colour the opinion, the opposing side will raise it and the court may give the evidence less weight. The expert's report must also carry a statement of truth and the Practice Direction 35 declaration, which cannot honestly be signed if an undisclosed interest exists [4].

The 'reasonable and informed third party' perspective and the court's own test for independence

The second edition asks not whether the surveyor believes there is a conflict, but whether a reasonable and informed third party, looking at the facts, would perceive one [1]. That is close to how courts think: judges are concerned with whether an expert is, and appears to be, independent of the parties. An expert who passes the subjective test ("I know I can be impartial") can still fail the objective one ("a fair-minded observer would doubt it").

For a RICS conflicts of interest expert witness surveyor, the conflict check must therefore be done from the outside looking in: not "do I feel conflicted?" but "what would opposing counsel make of this connection in cross-examination?"

Conflicts in practice: prior instructions, lenders, vendors, single joint experts and party wall appointments

Some situations arise again and again in property disputes.

Prior involvement with the property or a party. A surveyor who valued or surveyed the property for a lender, a vendor or a buyer, or who advised one neighbour before a dispute began, has knowledge and possibly loyalties that a third party would notice. The connection must be identified and either declined or disclosed with informed consent, and recorded.

Firm-level relationships. Conflicts are not personal only. A firm with a standing relationship with a developer, a lender or a managing agent may have a conflict even if the individual expert has never met them. The draft's emphasis on governance and record-keeping is aimed squarely at this [1].

Single joint experts. Under CPR Part 35 a single joint expert is instructed by both parties and owes the same duty to each [4]. Any prior link to either side should normally rule the surveyor out.

Party wall 'agreed surveyor' appointments. Under section 10 of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 the two owners may appoint one agreed surveyor to act for both, and a person who is a party to the matter cannot act as a surveyor at all. A party wall surveyor who later becomes an expert witness in a damage claim arising from the same works needs to think carefully about whether the two roles can be reconciled in the eyes of an informed observer.

Fee arrangements. Any arrangement that gives the expert a financial interest in the outcome is incompatible with the expert's duty to the court. The new standard's focus on informed consent and recording will make this harder to leave unspoken.

AI, confidentiality and expert reports: how the new standard sits alongside the 30 November 2026 expert witness standard

The second edition adds artificial intelligence as a new area within conflicts and confidentiality [1]. In an expert witness context the confidentiality dimension is immediate: an expert who uploads a confidential bundle, a privileged letter of instruction or a client's financial information to an AI tool may be disclosing confidential information to a third party, and may be doing so in breach of the terms on which the documents were provided.

RICS is approaching AI from several directions. The expert witness standard taking effect on 30 November 2026 deals with how surveyors use and disclose AI in expert work [3]. RICS also ran a pre-consultation questionnaire from 22 October to 9 November 2026 on proposed practice guidance on AI in conflict avoidance and dispute resolution, aimed at advisers, advocates, expert witnesses and other ADR practitioners [2], and is separately consulting on draft AI in real estate valuation guidance until 15 December 2026 [1]. The conflicts standard will tie AI use back to integrity, confidentiality and record-keeping.

What instructing solicitors should ask before an expert accepts instructions

Solicitors can save a great deal of trouble by asking at the outset whether the expert or their firm has acted for either party or on the property before, whether any ongoing relationship exists with the parties, their lenders, agents or insurers, whether the expert has any financial interest in the outcome, which AI tools will be used and how their use will be disclosed, and how the conflict check and any consents will be recorded. The answers should be in writing and kept on file, which is exactly what the second edition's emphasis on record-keeping anticipates [1].

A practical conflict checklist for surveyor expert witnesses

  • Run a conflict check against both parties, the property and connected entities before accepting any instruction, and record the result.
  • Apply the reasonable and informed third party test, not a personal comfort test.
  • Where a potential conflict exists, decline, or disclose it fully and obtain informed consent in writing from the instructing party, and consider whether the court should also be told.
  • Keep ongoing monitoring in mind: a conflict can arise mid-instruction if a new party joins or the firm takes on new work.
  • Treat confidential material with care, including when using AI tools, and disclose AI use in the report as the 5th edition expert witness standard requires from 30 November 2026 [3].
  • Make sure the Practice Direction 35 declaration can be signed truthfully [4].

This article is general information about a live consultation and is not legal advice.

FAQ

When does the RICS conflicts of interest consultation close?

The consultation on Conflicts of interest and confidentiality, Global, 2nd Edition opened on 5 November 2026 and closes at 23:59 on 27 January 2027 [1].

What is new in the second edition?

RICS says it clarifies and strengthens requirements for identifying, assessing, managing, recording and monitoring conflicts, with more emphasis on informed consent, governance, record-keeping, compliance and confidentiality, and adds new areas on third-party perceptions of conflicts and artificial intelligence [1].

What is the 'reasonable and informed third party' test?

It asks whether a reasonable and informed outside observer would perceive a conflict, rather than whether the surveyor personally believes one exists [1]. For expert witnesses it mirrors the court's concern with both actual and apparent independence.

How does this relate to the 30 November 2026 expert witness standard?

The fifth edition of Surveyors acting as expert witnesses takes effect on 30 November 2026 and governs expert conduct, including AI disclosure [3]. The conflicts standard, once finalised, will govern whether the instruction should be accepted in the first place and how conflicts and confidential information are handled throughout.

Conclusion

RICS is tightening the rules on conflicts at the same moment it tightens the rules on expert evidence. For surveyors who give evidence in building, valuation, party wall and boundary disputes, the next steps are practical: apply the reasonable and informed third party test in every conflict check, record every check and consent, review how confidential material and AI tools are used, align report templates with the 5th edition standard before 30 November 2026, and respond on iConsult, by comment, questionnaire or uploaded document, before 23:59 on 27 January 2027 so that the final standard reflects how expert witness work is actually done [1].

References

  1. RICS iConsult, Conflicts of interest and confidentiality, Global, 2nd Edition (consultation open 5 November 2026 to 27 January 2027). consultations.rics.org
  2. RICS, Upholding standards and professionalism: SRB's Q3 update, 10 September 2026. rics.org
  3. RICS, Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition (effective 30 November 2026). rics.org
  4. Civil Procedure Rules, Part 35: Experts and Assessors. justice.gov.uk

Related guides

No items found.