Expert Witness
Nov 15, 2026

Park Homes Investments v Avison Young (2026) EWHC 2713 (BP): What a £5.75m Valuation Negligence Claim Teaches About Scope of Duty and Expert Valuation Evidence (November 2026)

An October 2026 High Court ruling lets a £5.75m overvaluation claim against Avison Young proceed but strikes out borrower-conduct losses. Lessons for valuers, lenders, solicitors and expert witnesses.

A lender advanced roughly £8 million against park homes it had never seen, relying on a valuer's reports. When the operator collapsed and homes turned out to have been sold without the proceeds being accounted for, the lender sued the valuer. The High Court's October 2026 ruling in Park Homes Investments Ltd v Avison Young (UK) Ltd is the clearest recent illustration of why a valuation negligence expert witness decides these cases, and why the scope of a valuer's duty can cut a claim down before any expert is heard [1].

Key Takeaways

  • The claim against Avison Young survives, but only in part. Losses caused by the borrower's disposal of homes and failure to pay were struck out as falling outside the purpose of a valuation duty.
  • Park Homes Investments may still pursue an alleged overvaluation of up to £5.75 million.
  • The court said the valuation standards and the permissible range of values will require formal expert valuation evidence at trial.
  • Disputed conversations between the lender and the valuer's surveyors could not be resolved on paper. Witness statements from the valuer's own staff are evidence of fact, not expert opinion.
  • Instructing solicitors should define the retainer, the basis of value and the inspection scope before a dispute starts, not after.

The facts behind the valuation negligence expert witness question

Park Homes Investments Limited (PHIL) funded the Royale Group, which ran residential park home sites, through "stocking" arrangements. PHIL took title to specified homes with rights of repurchase and substitution, and Royale was to market the homes and apply the sale proceeds to PHIL's debt [1].

PHIL advanced about £8 million across two transactions: about £5 million in April 2020 for 46 homes, and about £3.2 million in January 2021 for 87 homes [1].

Avison Young (AY) produced five reports over two years:

Report Date Nature
1 April 2020 Desktop valuation
2 September 2020 Physical stock audit, charged at £50 per unit
3 January 2021 Valuation "subject to inspection"
4 February 2021 Inspection update with appendices
5 March 2022 Combined valuation and audit

In January 2021, 29 homes were listed as "sold". PHIL's managing director, Matthew Insley, asked AY to include them on the assumption that they had not been agreed for sale. What that exchange meant is disputed between the parties [1].

Royale paid about £1.5 million in January 2022 and about £2 million between April and June 2022 after PHIL exercised its put options. Royale then failed, and in 2023 PHIL discovered that homes had been sold without the proceeds being accounted for [1].

PHIL alleges that AY overvalued the homes and failed to flag signs of occupation and sales. AY says its retainers were limited to valuation and to confirming that the homes were "in situ", and that PHIL's losses flow from Royale's alleged fraud rather than from any valuation error [1].

What Chief Master Shuman decided

The judgment, handed down in the Business and Property Courts after a hearing on 7 and 8 May 2026, dealt with three sets of applications: AY's strike-out application, AY's summary judgment application, and PHIL's application to amend its case [1].

Amendments

PHIL's proposed "red flags" amendment, built on Mr Insley's account of an instruction to AY surveyor Mark Ebo, was dismissed. Its causation and loss-of-chance amendments were allowed [1].

Strike out

AY's strike-out application failed for both the valuation claims and the stock-audit claims. PHIL must, however, give further particulars of its valuation case [1].

Summary judgment and scope of duty

Summary judgment on the April 2020 report was partly granted to AY. Losses arising from Royale's disposal of homes, its retention of sale proceeds, its default and its inability to perform were struck out, because those losses fall outside the purpose of a valuation duty. PHIL may still pursue its claim for loss caused by the alleged overvaluation itself, up to £5.75 million [1].

This is the scope-of-duty principle in action. Since the Supreme Court's decision in Manchester Building Society v Grant Thornton (2021) UKSC 20, courts ask what risk the professional's advice was meant to guard against. A valuer who states the value of an asset does not, without more, take on the risk that a borrower will sell the asset and pocket the money.

The court was clear that disputed facts could not be resolved at this stage. AY surveyors Mark Ebo and Carys Chandler had given witness statements, but there had been no cross-examination.

Why the valuation negligence expert witness is still the decisive figure

The judgment leaves the central question for trial: were AY's values outside the range a reasonably competent valuer could have reached? The court said plainly that valuation standards and the permissible valuation range will require formal expert valuation evidence. PHIL had obtained preliminary expert input before serving its particulars, which is one reason the claim was not struck out [1].

Three points follow for anyone involved in a valuer negligence claim.

Witness of fact versus Part 35 expert

Mr Ebo and Ms Chandler are the valuers who did the work. Their statements explain what they did, what they were asked to do and what they saw. That is factual evidence. It cannot tell the court whether the resulting figures were negligent. Only an independent expert instructed under CPR Part 35, owing an overriding duty to the court, can do that.

The bracket is the battleground

Valuer negligence is rarely about a single "correct" figure. The expert must establish the acceptable range for each valuation date and show whether the reported figure fell outside it. For park homes, that means engaging with the specialised market, the condition and age of each unit, pitch fees and site licensing, and the realistic resale evidence available in 2020 and 2021.

The retainer defines the duty

AY's defence turns on what it was instructed to do. A desktop valuation, a £50-per-unit stock audit and a valuation "subject to inspection" each carry different expectations. The expert must assess each report against what that report said it was, not against an idealised full inspection.

Expert evidence practice: CPR Part 35, Practice Direction 35 and the RICS standard

Instructing solicitors preparing a valuation negligence expert witness for a case of this kind should expect the report to address, at minimum:

  • the basis of value adopted in each report and whether it matched the instruction;
  • the comparable and market evidence available at each valuation date;
  • the acceptable margin for the asset class, with reasons;
  • the scope of inspection that a competent valuer would have undertaken for the stated purpose and fee;
  • whether a competent valuer confirming homes were "in situ" would have recorded signs of occupation or sale, if that is what the retainer required;
  • what the retainer did not cover.

Under CPR Part 35 and Practice Direction 35 the report must set out the expert's qualifications, the material relied upon, the range of opinion where there is one, and a statement of truth. The RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, in its 5th edition effective from 30 November 2026, reinforces the same duties of independence, transparency and clear separation between fact and opinion. An expert who strays into advocacy for the instructing party will damage the case, not help it.

What this means for lenders, investors and funders

  • Define the purpose of each valuation in writing. If the lender needs the valuer to flag occupation or sale, say so and pay for it.
  • Do not treat a desktop report or a per-unit audit as a full inspection.
  • Keep a contemporaneous record of every instruction given by telephone. The disputed Insley–Ebo exchange shows how quickly an oral instruction becomes a litigation issue.
  • Take early expert valuation advice before issuing proceedings. The court noted that PHIL had done so, and that helped the claim survive.

What this means for surveyors and solicitors

  • Valuers should confine each report to its stated purpose and record the limits of what was inspected and assumed.
  • Retain file notes for every conversation with the client, including requests to include or exclude units.
  • Solicitors acting for claimants should plead the overvaluation loss separately from loss caused by borrower misconduct, because the latter will not survive a scope-of-duty challenge.
  • Experts should be instructed with a clear brief covering each report and each date, and should be ready to explain their bracket methodology in cross-examination.

Conclusion

Park Homes Investments v Avison Young is an interim ruling, not a final finding of negligence. Its lessons are nonetheless immediate. The scope-of-duty principle protects valuers from losses caused by a borrower's dishonesty, but it does not protect them from a proven overvaluation. Whether this £5.75 million claim succeeds will depend on the quality of the valuation negligence expert witness evidence on both sides. Lenders should instruct clearly, valuers should document carefully, and both should expect the expert's bracket analysis to decide the outcome. The full judgment is available on the National Archives Find Case Law service [1].

References

[1] Park Homes Investments Limited v Avison Young (UK) Limited (2026) EWHC 2713 (BP), High Court (Business and Property Courts), Chief Master Shuman. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk

Related guides

No items found.