The classic signs: diagonal cracks stepping through brickwork (often wider at the top), cracks appearing after dry summers or near large trees, doors and windows sticking, and sloping floors — particularly in combination. None of these prove subsidence on their own; plenty of movement is historic and stable. An investigation distinguishes live subsidence from the harmless history most older houses carry.
No — underpinning is the last resort, needed in only a minority of confirmed cases. Most subsidence traces to a treatable cause: tree roots drying clay soil, a leaking drain washing out ground, or seasonal movement that stabilises once the cause is managed. Fix the cause, monitor, repair the cracking — that is the usual sequence. Be wary of anyone proposing underpinning from a single glance.
Sometimes — but go in informed. Subsidence claims typically carry a higher excess, and a recorded claim affects future premiums and sale disclosures, so trivial or stable movement may not justify one. An independent investigation first tells you whether the damage is genuinely subsidence, what remediation is proportionate, and gives you your own expert position alongside the insurer's loss adjuster.