Two sets of rules that shape surveyor expert evidence land on the same Monday. On 30 November 2026 the RICS expert witness standard 5th edition becomes effective for every RICS member worldwide, and on the same date Phase 2 of Awaab's Law starts to bite for social landlords in England [1][2]. For solicitors who instruct chartered surveyors, and for the surveyors who write the reports, that leaves fifteen days from today, Sunday 15 November 2026, to update letters of instruction, report templates and declarations.
Key Takeaways
- The RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, global 5th edition, was published in July 2026 and takes effect on 30 November 2026, with a companion practice guidance document [1].
- The biggest changes concern disclosure of AI use, disclosure of regular instructions from the same party, longer and more analytical reports, and a continued ban on new conditional fee arrangements [1].
- Awaab's Law Phase 2 extends fixed investigation and repair timescales to seven more hazard groups from 30 November 2026, which will generate more housing-conditions disputes and more demand for single joint experts [2].
- Reports and instructions drafted before the deadline should be audited now so that nothing served after 30 November fails the new standard.
What the RICS Expert Witness Standard 5th Edition Changes
RICS has published the 5th edition as a professional standard with a companion practice guidance document, Additional guidance for surveyors acting as expert witnesses, and a combined "tribunal-friendly" version [1]. It applies to all RICS members worldwide, although the rules of the relevant court or tribunal take precedence where they conflict [1]. The table maps each headline change to the action it demands.
| Change in the 5th edition | What experts and instructing parties must do |
|---|
| Artificial intelligence — disclose where AI or similar tools contributed, identify work done by others or through AI, explain methods and tools, and reference AI-derived material; AI output may be treated like hearsay [1]. | Add an AI and third-party declaration to every report; keep a methods log. |
| Conflicts of interest — regular instructions from the same party, especially where it supplies a large share of the expert's income, must be disclosed; conflicts declared promptly, withdrawal considered, and the tribunal's direction sought once proceedings begin [1]. | Ask about repeat instructions at the outset; keep a record of income by instructing party. |
| Expert reports — list all assumptions, give alternative conclusions where legal assumptions are disputed, address competing schools of thought, give separate opinions for different factual scenarios, identify third-party work and explain why alternatives were rejected [1]. | Expect longer, more analytical reports; build an assumptions schedule and alternative-conclusions section into the template. |
| Conditional fees — the ban stays; a narrow exception covers only arrangements pre-dating the appointment, where tribunal rules allow, the client is warned it may affect weight, and a specified declaration is made. No new conditional arrangements [1]. | Check every retainer for success-based terms and remove them. |
| Instructions — verify before accepting, record all instructions and changes, summarise material instructions in the report [1]. | Written instructions, written variations, a dated instructions log. |
| Expert and advocate roles — allowed only where the tribunal permits, it is proportionate and the client has been advised; the tribunal must be told and advocacy kept separate from opinion [1]. | Decide and record the role at the outset. |
| Accountability — tribunal criticism, adverse costs, contempt, negligence claims and RICS disciplinary action [1]. | Treat the standard as a compliance document. |
The AI Disclosure Point in Practice
The AI provisions are the change most likely to catch out an otherwise careful expert. Many surveyors already use software to measure from drawings, draft standard paragraphs or search comparables. Under the RICS expert witness standard 5th edition each such contribution must be identified, the method explained and the output verified personally, because the expert remains responsible for every opinion [1].
A short declaration paragraph, a methods log kept during the instruction, and clear attribution of any third-party or AI-derived material meet the requirement. Instructing solicitors should ask the question directly in the letter of instruction.
How CPR Part 35 Fits With the RICS Expert Witness Standard 5th Edition
In England and Wales the legal framework for expert evidence is Part 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules and Practice Direction 35 [4]. The main provisions are:
- Rule 35.3 — the expert's overriding duty is to the court, and it overrides any obligation to the instructing or paying party.
- Rule 35.4 — no party may call an expert or put in an expert's report without the court's permission.
- Rule 35.6 — a party may put written questions to an expert about the report.
- Rule 35.7 — the court may direct that evidence on an issue is given by a single joint expert.
- Rule 35.12 — the court may direct discussions between experts and a joint statement of agreed and disputed issues.
- Practice Direction 35 — sets out the required content of a report, including the statement of truth and the expert's declaration.
The RICS standard does not replace these rules; it adds professional obligations on top of them, and the court's rules win where they conflict [1]. A report that meets the 5th edition will almost always satisfy Practice Direction 35, but the reverse is no longer true.
Awaab's Law Phase 2: The Same Date, A Different Workload
On 30 November 2026 social landlords in England must meet fixed timescales for seven further hazard groups under the Hazards in Social Housing (Prescribed Requirements) (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2026, announced by the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government on 13 July 2026 [2]. The new groups are:
- electrical hazards
- falls (on the level, on stairs and between levels)
- fire and explosions
- excess cold
- excess heat
- structural collapse and falling elements
- domestic hygiene, including pest infestations
The timescales are unchanged from Phase 1. Emergency hazards must be investigated and made safe within 24 hours. Significant hazards must be investigated within 10 working days, a written summary given to the tenant within 3 working days of the investigation concluding, safety works completed within 5 working days, and longer-term works started within 12 weeks [2]. Phase 1, covering damp and mould and emergency hazards, has applied since 27 October 2025, and Phase 3 is due in 2027 [2].
Every disputed investigation becomes a question of expert evidence, and the Pre-Action Protocol for Housing Conditions Claims (England) encourages a single joint expert. Surveyors taking on that work from 30 November will be writing under the 5th edition from the first report; see The Survey Merchant's housing disrepair expert witness service.
Why single joint experts matter: Harvey v Heaver
The value of a well-prepared single joint expert was shown in Harvey v Heaver and another (neutral citation 2026 EWHC 1671 (KB)), decided on 3 July 2026 [3]. The High Court found a privately rented house near Chichester unfit for human habitation under section 9A of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985. Neither party challenged the single joint expert's findings, and the court relied on them to order specific performance of the works listed in the expert's report [3]. The case is a reminder that where a single joint expert's report is clear on causation and scope, it can decide the outcome without a battle of experts.
What Solicitors and Surveyor Experts Should Change Now
- Letters of instruction should ask about AI use, repeat instructions and any pre-existing fee arrangements, set out the factual scenarios and legal assumptions to be addressed, and confirm every variation in writing.
- Report templates need a conflicts paragraph, an AI and third-party declaration with a methods log, a schedule of assumptions, a section on alternative conclusions, a summary of material instructions and the current Practice Direction 35 declaration [4].
- Retainers and panel terms must be checked for success-based payment; see the separate note on who pays expert witness fees in a property dispute.
- Timetables should allow for the longer reports the standard anticipates, in housing work and in construction adjudication alike.
Two-Week Countdown Checklist
| Days before 30 November | Action |
|---|
| 15 to 11 days | Read the 5th edition and companion guidance. Identify every open instruction that will still be live on 30 November. |
| 10 to 8 days | Update report templates: assumptions schedule, alternative conclusions, AI and third-party declaration, conflicts paragraph, instructions summary. |
| 7 to 5 days | Review all retainers and panel terms for conditional fee wording. Remove or re-paper. |
| 4 to 2 days | Agree with instructing solicitors how in-flight reports will be finalised, and whether any served after 30 November need a supplementary compliance statement. |
| 1 day | Brief support staff on the methods log and record-keeping. Diarise Awaab's Law Phase 2 timescales for any social-housing instructions. |
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the RICS 5th edition apply to reports already served before 30 November 2026?
The standard takes effect on 30 November 2026. Reports served before that date were written under the previous guidance, but any supplementary report, joint statement or oral evidence given after that date should meet the new requirements.
Can an expert still use AI to help draft a report?
Yes, provided the use is disclosed, the method explained, the output verified and the expert takes personal responsibility for the opinions expressed [1].
Does Awaab's Law Phase 2 apply to private landlords?
The Phase 2 regulations apply to social housing landlords in England [2].
Conclusion
The RICS expert witness standard 5th edition and Awaab's Law Phase 2 arrive together on 30 November 2026, and together they raise the bar for surveyor expert evidence in exactly the field where demand is about to grow. The practical response is not complicated: update letters of instruction, rebuild report templates around assumptions, alternatives and AI disclosure, remove conditional fee terms, and keep better records. Solicitors and surveyors who complete that work in the next fifteen days will be serving compliant evidence from day one. Those who need an expert who already works to the new standard can contact The Survey Merchant's expert witness panel.
References
- Rimkus, "RICS 2026 Expert Witness Guidance: Key Changes for Surveyors", 10 August 2026 (updated 1 September 2026). rimkus.com
- Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, "Safer homes for 4m tenants with quicker action on dangerous homes", 13 July 2026. gov.uk
- Devonshires, "Clarifying the Fitness for Human Habitation Test: Harvey v Heaver and another, 2026 EWHC 1671 (KB)", 10 July 2026. insights.devonshires.com
- Ministry of Justice, Civil Procedure Rules, Practice Direction 35 – Experts and Assessors. justice.gov.uk