Expert Witness
Nov 20, 2026

Moller v One Touch Solution (2026) EWHC 2559: When Does a Professional Negligence Claim Need Expert Evidence? Lessons for Surveyors and Those Who Instruct Them (November 2026)

The High Court rejected a late argument that a professional negligence claim needed expert evidence. We explain the ruling, the rule in surveyor negligence cases, and why the point must be raised at the directions stage.

It is often said that a professional cannot be found negligent without evidence from a member of the same profession. For surveyors that principle is usually traced to Sansom v Metcalfe Hambleton, where the Court of Appeal held that a structural engineer's view was not a sound basis for finding a chartered surveyor negligent. The rule matters to every claimant considering a claim over a survey or valuation, and to every surveyor defending one.

The High Court's judgment in Moller and others v One Touch Solution Ltd (in creditors' voluntary liquidation) and Hiscox Insurance Company Ltd (2026) EWHC 2559, dated 9 October 2026, shows the limits of that rule. The defendant argued for the first time in its trial skeleton argument that the claimants could not succeed without expert evidence on the standard of care. Miss Recorder Bignell KC, sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge, rejected the argument. This article explains why, and what it means for property disputes where expert evidence is, or is not, on the table.

The case in outline

The claim was brought by 28 investors who bought long leases of individual rooms in care homes being developed by a group that later collapsed. The purchases were made between September 2017 and March 2019, typically for £70,000 to £110,000 per unit, with a promised fixed return of generally 10% a year and buy-back guarantees. The gross sums paid by the claimants totalled £2,814,195.20. Only one of the group's 22 care home developments was ever in operation.

The investors bought through One Touch, a London property investment intermediary, or through its sub-agent. They said One Touch presented itself as an adviser that carried out due diligence, owed them duties in contract and in tort, and made statements about the safety of the investment that were wrong. One Touch said it was only a marketing agent for the developer.

The trial was of liability only, with insurance coverage and the amount of the losses to be dealt with later. According to a report in the insurance trade press published on 12 October 2026, the court found that One Touch owed the investors duties in contract and under the general law, that nearly all of the claims succeeded, and that a small number failed, including two that were barred because the investors had earlier accepted binding Property Ombudsman decisions.

The expert evidence argument

Neither side called an expert of any discipline. Both had stated in their directions questionnaires that expert evidence was not necessary, and that was the agreed position at the costs and case management conference.

In its skeleton argument for trial, One Touch changed course. It accepted that not every professional negligence claim needs expert evidence. But it argued that the questions in this case, including what due diligence a reasonably competent investment intermediary would carry out, could not be answered without an expert. It relied on the standard authorities, including Pantelli Associates v Corporate City Developments Number Two Ltd, ACD (Landscape Architects) Ltd v Overall and Sansom v Metcalfe Hambleton.

The claimants replied that whether expert evidence is desirable and proportionate depends on the case, that both sides had agreed none was needed, and that One Touch would have needed the court's permission to alter that position.

What the judge decided

The judge described the defendant's change of stance at trial as surprising. One Touch could have asked for further information about the claim, raised the point at the case management conference, or raised it at an interim disclosure hearing in December 2025. It did none of these, and it made no application to adjourn the trial.

She went on to hold that, on the facts of the case, expert evidence would not have been desirable or proportionate.

The reason becomes clear from the rest of the judgment. The court was able to measure One Touch's conduct against its own published description of what it did. Its website, videos and advertorials called investors "clients", said it offered property investment advice, and said it carried out due diligence including site visits and a solicitor's review of the fine print. The judge treated those materials as the best guide to the role One Touch had taken on. The evidence at trial was that the site visits and the solicitor's review did not happen, and that the company knew the developer had no track record as a care home developer or operator.

Where a business has said what it will do and has not done it, a court does not need an expert to say that a competent member of the trade would have acted differently.

How this fits with surveyor negligence claims

The decision does not weaken the general rule for surveyors. It marks out where the rule applies.

Where expert evidence is still needed. In a claim that a building surveyor missed a defect, the court has to know what a reasonably competent surveyor would have seen and reported on an inspection of that type. In a negligent valuation claim, it has to know the range of figures a competent valuer could have reached. Those are questions of professional practice and judgment. A claim of that kind that reaches trial without supporting evidence from a suitably qualified surveyor is in serious difficulty, and under Pantelli it is open to criticism for being pleaded at all.

Where it may not be. The recognised exceptions cover cases where no question of professional judgment arises. A surveyor who does not inspect at all, who reports on the wrong property, who ignores express instructions, or who fails to do something the terms of engagement or the report itself say was done, may be found in breach without expert evidence, because the court can see the failure for itself.

Moller sits in the second category. For surveyors the practical point is that marketing material, terms of engagement and the wording of the report define the service promised. If a website promises a full inspection of roof voids and the surveyor does not look, no expert is needed to prove the shortfall.

Raise the expert evidence point early or lose it

The second lesson is procedural. Under the Civil Procedure Rules no party may rely on expert evidence without the court's permission, and the court restricts it to what is reasonably required. The time to decide whether an expert is needed is the directions stage.

A party that agrees no expert is required, and then argues at trial that the other side's case fails for want of one, can expect the response One Touch received. The objection should be made at the case management conference, with a draft direction identifying the discipline and the issues.

For those instructing surveyors as expert witnesses, this has two consequences:

  • take the surveyor's view at the outset on whether the issues are ones of professional judgment that need expert evidence, and say so in the directions questionnaire;
  • if the position changes, apply promptly for permission. Do not leave it to the skeleton argument.

Other points worth noting

The judgment is also a warning about documents. The court found that email accounts of several staff had been deleted, in breach of the duty to preserve documents, and that this undermined the credibility of the explanation given for missing records. The company's own website was disclosed only after a court order. Surveyors facing a claim should preserve the whole file, including emails, photographs, site notes and earlier drafts, from the moment a complaint is made.

The Property Ombudsman had previously found in the company's favour on complaints by some of the investors. The trial judge noted those decisions had been made on paper representations. A favourable ombudsman outcome did not prevent the court reaching a different view for investors who had not accepted a binding decision.

How Survey Merchant can help

Survey Merchant connects clients, solicitors and insurers with chartered surveyors who act as expert witnesses in building defect, valuation, boundary, party wall and professional negligence disputes. If you are unsure whether your dispute needs expert evidence, an early conversation with an experienced surveyor expert is the quickest way to find out.

Frequently asked questions

Does a professional negligence claim against a surveyor always need expert evidence?

Almost always, where the complaint is about professional judgment, such as what should have been spotted on inspection or what a property was worth. The exceptions are cases where the failure is obvious without professional input, such as work that was promised and not done.

Why was expert evidence not required in Moller v One Touch Solution?

Both parties had agreed that none was needed, the defendant raised the point only in its trial skeleton argument, and the judge held that expert evidence would not have been desirable or proportionate on the facts.

When should the need for expert evidence be raised?

At the directions stage, in the directions questionnaire and at the case management conference. Permission of the court is required before any party can rely on an expert.

Can a firm's website affect what duty it owes?

Yes. In this case the court treated the company's own website and promotional material as the best guide to the role it had taken on.

This article is a general summary for information only and is not legal advice. It is based on the published judgment so far as it deals with expert evidence and on press reporting of the outcome on liability.

Related guides

No items found.