The flooring in a group of new homes at Wembley Park has failed. The main contractor puts the cost of replacing it at £2,907,908. The installer says the supplier is to blame, and the supplier says the claim is years too late. On 3 November 2026 the Technology and Construction Court (TCC) decided that the fight must go on. In Loughton Contracts Plc v The Amtico Company Limited (2026) EWHC 2814 (TCC), Mr Justice Constable refused to strike the claim out or give summary judgment, but he also refused to let it sit on hold for another six months. The judgment is a practical guide to limitation, exclusion clauses and evidence in a building defects claim.
Key takeaways
- The claim survives. Applications for summary judgment and strike-out were refused.
- Limitation is a real threat. The supplier says about 97% of the orders by value were delivered more than six years before the claim form was issued.
- Proof matters, even for the defendant. The supplier had not shown delivery dates, the contract terms or the reasonableness of its exclusion clauses clearly enough to win without a trial.
- Missing a deadline was serious. The installer never served Particulars of Claim. The judge called the failure "serious and significant" but held that striking out would be disproportionate.
- No more long stays. A further stay to April 2027 was not justified.
What happened at Wembley Park
Loughton Contracts installed flooring supplied by Amtico in residential developments at Wembley Park, London, between 2018 and 2020. The flooring later failed. The main contractor, McLaren Construction (Regeneration) Limited, holds Loughton responsible for the replacement cost. McLaren has not yet issued its own court claim.
To protect its position against the supplier, Loughton issued a claim on 15 October 2025. The timetable then slipped:
| Date | Event |
|---|
| 15 October 2025 | Protective claim form issued |
| 7 January 2026 | Particulars of Claim due. Not served |
| 5 February 2026 | Claim stayed until 5 October 2026, without the supplier being heard |
| 25 September 2026 | Supplier applies for strike-out and summary judgment |
| 27 October 2026 | Hearing |
| 3 November 2026 | Judgment |
The supplier's arguments
Limitation. A claim for breach of contract must normally be brought within six years. Amtico said that any claim for goods delivered before 15 October 2019 was out of time. On its figures, orders worth £578,071.54 fell before that date, and only 18 orders worth £18,677.95 fell after it.
Contract terms. Amtico relied on its standard terms. These were said to exclude indirect loss and third-party claims, cap liability at the contract price, and set a two-year time limit running from knowledge of the problem.
Tort and contribution. Amtico argued that claims in negligence for pure economic loss, and for a contribution, had no real prospect of success.
Procedural default. Finally, it said the claim should be struck out because Particulars of Claim had never been served.
Why the court refused to end the claim
The judge held that these points could not be decided summarily.
- Delivery dates. The supplier's evidence of when goods were delivered was not complete enough to prove the limitation defence at this stage.
- Incorporation of terms. Whether the standard terms formed part of each order, through a course of dealing, needed fuller evidence.
- Reasonableness. Exclusion and limitation clauses in standard terms must satisfy the reasonableness test in the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977. That could not be resolved on the material before the court.
- Tort claims. It was premature to strike these out.
On the missed deadline, the judge was direct about the installer's explanation: "This is plainly a reason. It is not a good reason." Even so, relief from sanctions was granted, because ending a claim of this size for that default would be out of proportion.
The installer did not get everything it wanted. Its request for a further stay to 5 April 2027 was refused. The judge invited submissions on a short, tightly defined stay, directions for pleadings, targeted disclosure and possible preliminary issues.
A protective claim form buys time. It does not buy an open-ended pause.
Where surveyor and expert evidence comes in
No expert evidence was before the court at this hearing. The applications were argued on witness statements about orders, invoices and terms. But the next stage cannot avoid it. To plead a defects case, the installer will need to say why the flooring failed. That is a technical question, and the possible answers point in different directions:
- a manufacturing or product fault, which points at the supplier;
- poor installation or adhesive choice, which points at the installer;
- moisture in the subfloor or inadequate drying time, which may point at the main contractor or programme; or
- the conditions in which the homes were used after handover.
Sorting between these needs inspection, sampling and testing by a suitably qualified expert, and a clear record of which product went into which plot and when. A party who waits for someone else's claim before investigating risks losing both the evidence and the limitation argument.
When the case reaches trial, expert evidence will be controlled by CPR Part 35, and any surveyor acting as an expert will also be bound by the RICS standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses (5th edition), which takes effect on 30 November 2026.
Lessons for building defect disputes
1. Count limitation from delivery or completion, not discovery. In contract, time usually runs from the breach. For goods, that is normally delivery. Latent defects can be out of time in contract before anyone notices them.
2. Check the supply terms before the job, not after. Caps at the contract price and short notification periods are common in suppliers' terms. A subcontractor caught between a main contractor's full claim and a supplier's cap carries the gap.
3. Keep delivery and batch records. Both sides struggled on documents. Delivery notes, batch numbers and plot-by-plot installation records can decide a limitation defence.
4. Investigate early. Commission an independent inspection and report as soon as a pattern of failure appears. Early findings shape who is blamed and what is pleaded.
5. Do not treat a stay as the plan. If a protective claim is issued, use the time to prepare the case. The court expects progress.
Frequently asked questions
Has the court decided who is responsible for the failed flooring?
No. This was a ruling on interim applications. The cause of the failure and liability for it have not been decided.
Is the limitation defence dead?
No. The supplier can still run it at trial or as a preliminary issue. The court only held that it was not proved clearly enough for summary judgment.
What is a protective claim?
It is a claim form issued to stop time running under the Limitation Act 1980 while the claimant waits to see whether it will itself be sued or completes its investigations.
Do homeowners need to do anything?
The dispute is between businesses in the supply chain. Owners of new homes with flooring or other defects should report them in writing to the developer and, where relevant, the warranty provider, and keep dated photographs.
Conclusion
Loughton v Amtico shows how quickly a building defects claim can turn into an argument about dates and paperwork. The supplier's limitation point is strong on its face, but it was not backed by enough evidence to end the case early. The installer kept its claim alive, but was told plainly to get on with it.
Contractors, developers and suppliers facing a pattern of defects should secure their records, check limitation dates for each supply or handover, and obtain an independent technical report before positions are fixed. Good evidence gathered early is usually cheaper than a missed deadline later.
This article is general information on a recent judgment and is not legal advice.
Sources