Expert Witness
Nov 17, 2026

Mulalley v Sto (2026) EWHC 2681 (TCC): Default Judgment on a Building Liability Order Still Needs Evidence – What It Means for Expert Witnesses in Cladding Claims (November 2026)

On 20 October 2026 the TCC entered default judgment against Sto SE in Mulalley's cladding contribution claim, but left the amount to be assessed after 1 December 2026. What expert witnesses should prepare.

The defendant filed nothing. No acknowledgment of service, no defence, and nobody at the hearing. Even so, the Technology and Construction Court would not simply sign off the sum claimed. The Mulalley v Sto default judgment on a building liability order shows that expert evidence still matters when a cladding claim goes unanswered [1][2]. Judgment was handed down on 20 October 2026, and the amount will be decided at a later hearing.

Key Takeaways

  • Default judgment was entered, but not for a fixed sum. The amount of the contribution is to be assessed at a further hearing after 1 December 2026 [1].
  • "Just and equitable" needs a judge. Both the contribution claim and the Building Liability Order turn on an evaluation the court must make itself [1][2].
  • Evidence is still required. Commentators advise claimants to budget for a quantum hearing with full factual and expert evidence [1].
  • Experts should prepare as if the claim were contested. An unopposed hearing is not an untested one.

The Background to Mulalley v Sto

Mulalley & Co Limited was the design and build contractor for the overcladding of residential tower blocks. The works used the StoTherm Classic system, with combustible EPS insulation and an organic render. The system was specified and supplied by Sto Limited (Sto UK) [1][2].

In Martlet Homes Ltd v Mulalley (2022) EWHC 1813 (TCC), the court held that the system did not comply with Building Regulations requirement B4(1). Mulalley was ordered to pay Martlet £10,799,982.33 [1].

Mulalley then claimed a contribution from Sto UK under the Civil Liability (Contribution) Act 1978. The claim relied on Sto UK's liability under section 149 of the Building Safety Act 2022 (BSA), which deals with construction products [1].

Sto UK entered administration in January 2025, and the claim against it was caught by the statutory moratorium [1][2]. Mulalley therefore joined Sto UK's German parent, Sto SE & Co KGaA, and asked for a Building Liability Order (BLO) under section 130 of the BSA. A BLO can extend a company's building-safety liability to an associated company [1][3].

What the Court Decided

Sto SE filed no acknowledgment of service and no defence. Mulalley applied for default judgment. The application was heard on 16 October 2026 by Constable J, and only Mulalley appeared [2].

  • Was default judgment entered? Yes [1][2].
  • For the specific sum claimed? No. The court refused a specified amount [1][2].
  • What happens next? The contribution is to be assessed at a hearing after 1 December 2026 [1].
  • Can Sto SE respond? It may apply to set the judgment aside within 28 days of service of the order [2].

The reasoning is simple. The £10.8 million judgment against Mulalley is fixed. The contribution is not. Under section 2(1) of the 1978 Act, a contribution is whatever the court finds "just and equitable". A BLO under section 130 also requires the court to decide that it is just and equitable to extend liability to the associate [1][3].

A precise figure in a claim form is not the same as a figure the court has assessed.

Mulalley v Sto Default Judgment: Why Expert Evidence Still Matters

A "just and equitable" share cannot be worked out from a claim form. The court needs material to weigh. One law firm's November 2026 bulletin puts it plainly: claimants "should budget for a quantum hearing with full factual and expert evidence" [1].

At an assessment hearing in a cladding case, experts would usually be asked to address:

  • What was wrong. How the external wall system failed to meet the Building Regulations.
  • Who caused what. The parts played by product design, specification, installation and inspection.
  • The remedy. Whether the remedial scheme was reasonable and necessary.
  • The cost. Whether the sums paid were reasonable.

The disciplines involved can include building surveyors, fire engineers, facade specialists and quantity surveyors.

Because nobody may be there to challenge the evidence, the report has to do all the work. It should explain the method, show the investigations, and deal with other possible causes.

Duties of Expert Witnesses in Building Liability Order Claims

Under CPR Part 35 and Practice Direction 35, an expert's overriding duty is to the court. That duty does not shrink because the other side is silent. An expert must still set out the facts and assumptions relied on, and must give a balanced opinion.

Surveyors face a further change this month. The RICS professional standard Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition, takes effect on 30 November 2026. It says the expert's primary duty is to the tribunal, requires any use of artificial intelligence in the work to be identified in the report, and requires legitimate alternative views to be set out [4].

Practical Steps for Building Owners and Advisers

  • Do not treat default judgment as the finish line. Plan for an assessment hearing.
  • Instruct experts early. Evidence on cause, scheme and cost takes time to prepare.
  • Keep records. Investigation reports, specifications, invoices and photographs all support the expert's work.
  • Check the corporate group. Where the original company is insolvent, a BLO against an associate may be the only route to recovery.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a Building Liability Order?

An order under section 130 of the Building Safety Act 2022 that can make an associated company liable for another company's building-safety liability, where the court finds that just and equitable [1][3].

Did Mulalley win?

It obtained default judgment, but the amount has not been decided. That will be assessed at a later hearing [1][2].

Is the case finished?

No. A further hearing is due after 1 December 2026, and Sto SE may apply to set the judgment aside [1][2].

Conclusion

Mulalley v Sto is a reminder that silence from a defendant does not remove the need for proof. Where the law asks what is "just and equitable", a judge must decide, and a judge needs evidence.

Building owners and contractors with cladding claims should line up their expert evidence now. Surveyors acting as experts should check their reports against CPR Part 35 and the new RICS standard before 30 November 2026.

This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Take advice on your own circumstances.

References

  • [1] Mayer Brown, "Legal Developments in Construction Law: November 2026" (16 November 2026). mayerbrown.com
  • [2] Stephenson Harwood, "Default Judgment on Building Liability Orders" (22 October 2026). stephensonharwood.com
  • [3] Brodies, "Default judgement and building liability orders: lessons from historic cladding claims" (23 October 2026). brodies.com
  • [4] RICS, Surveyors acting as expert witnesses, 5th edition (July 2026, effective 30 November 2026). rics.org

Related guides

No items found.