A freeholder demanded almost £1.5 million from leaseholders in advance for major works. The leaseholders' expert told the tribunal that much of the work was unnecessary and that he would tear up the specification and start again. On 23 October 2026 the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) went further than the tribunal below and held that the advance charges would not be payable at all.
Albemarle Ealing No.1 Limited v Fahim and other leaseholders (2026) UKUT 408 (LC), decided by Upper Tribunal Judge Elizabeth Cooke, is a practical lesson in what expert surveying evidence can achieve in a service charge dispute, and in what happens to a landlord whose specification cannot be costed.
The background
Greystoke Court on Hanger Lane, London W5, comprises three blocks containing 47 flats. The leaseholders of 38 of them brought an application to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) under section 27A of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, which lets the tribunal decide whether service charges are payable.
Several items were in issue, including fire doors (£146,533), lift works and insurance. The largest by far was a demand dated 8 August 2024 for £1,487,349.48 in advance for major works. A contractor's estimate for the works stood at £1,489,174.59. The building had been the subject of a London Fire Brigade enforcement notice in August 2021.
What the expert said
The leaseholders relied on an expert, who is not named in the Upper Tribunal's decision. His evidence, as recorded by the tribunal, was direct:
- much of the proposed work was unnecessary or superfluous;
- the specification was poor;
- he would start again.
The landlord's evidence came from its director. He was a witness of fact, not an independent expert.
The First-tier Tribunal described the specification as "woefully inadequate". It concluded that the document gave no proper basis for costing the works, and for that reason declined to make any determination on the major works charge. It had separately granted the landlord conditional dispensation from the statutory consultation requirements on 16 June 2026, with a condition that disputes be referred to an independent surveyor nominated by the leaseholders at the landlord's cost.
What the Upper Tribunal decided
The landlord appealed, arguing that the First-tier Tribunal should have decided the question, for example by adjourning for better evidence.
The Upper Tribunal agreed that the tribunal should not have left the point undecided, but the result was worse for the landlord. Judge Cooke set aside the refusal to decide and substituted her own finding under sections 19(2) and 27A(3) of the 1985 Act: the advance charges for the major works would not be payable if properly demanded, because they were not reasonable in amount. A specification that lacked quantities could not support a demand of that size.
She also closed off an escape route. Neither consultation nor dispensation could enable the landlord to recover those charges. Dispensation deals with the consultation process. It does nothing to make an unreasonable sum reasonable.
On the fire doors, the First-tier Tribunal had allowed one-sixth of the amount by reference to the work actually done. The Upper Tribunal held that the landlord had failed to prove that the remainder was a reasonable advance charge, treated evidence about leaseholders' arrears as inadmissible and irrelevant, and set the one-sixth finding aside. The detailed treatment of that item is set out in the decision.
Why the specification mattered so much
An on-account service charge must be no greater than is reasonable. To test that, a tribunal needs to know what work is proposed, why it is needed, and how the price has been built up. A specification without quantities leaves each of those questions open. A contractor's lump-sum estimate priced against a vague document tells the tribunal very little.
That is where independent expert evidence did its work in this case. The expert did not simply say the price was too high. He attacked the foundation: the scope was wrong and the document describing it was not fit for pricing.
Lessons for surveyors preparing specifications
- Survey first, specify second. A specification should follow from a recorded inspection that identifies each defect and the remedy proposed.
- Include quantities. Measured items allow tenders to be compared and allow a tribunal to see what is being bought.
- Separate the necessary from the desirable. Repairs required by the lease or by an enforcement notice should be distinguished from improvements and optional extras.
- Expect scrutiny. On a large scheme, assume that an independent surveyor instructed by the leaseholders will read every line.
Lessons for surveyors acting as expert witnesses
In the First-tier Tribunal, expert evidence is governed by rule 19 of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Property Chamber) Rules 2013. The expert's duty is to help the tribunal on matters within their expertise, and that duty overrides any obligation to the party instructing or paying them. The principles are the same as those under CPR Part 35 in the courts.
Good practice follows from that:
- Inspect the building and say what you saw.
- Take the specification item by item and say whether each item is necessary, and why.
- Where you disagree with the cost, offer your own costed view where you can.
- Do not act as an advocate. The contrast in this case between an independent expert and a company director giving factual evidence was plain.
Lessons for leaseholders and landlords
Leaseholders facing a large advance demand should ask for the specification and the priced tender, and consider an independent building surveyor's review before paying or disputing. Expert evidence is often what turns a general sense of grievance into a case a tribunal can act on.
Landlords and managing agents should recognise that a rushed specification is a false economy. If the document cannot support the demand, the charge may be irrecoverable until the exercise is done again properly.
When to instruct an expert witness building surveyor
Consider independent expert evidence where major works are costed in six or seven figures, where the scope appears to go beyond repair, where fire safety works are being priced without a clear schedule, or where a section 27A application is likely. Survey Merchant's chartered building surveyors review specifications and tenders and prepare expert reports for tribunal and court proceedings.
Frequently asked questions
What did the Upper Tribunal decide in Albemarle Ealing v Fahim?
It held that advance service charges of about £1.49 million for major works at Greystoke Court would not be payable if demanded, because they were not reasonable in amount. The specification lacked quantities and gave no proper basis for costing.
Can dispensation from consultation rescue an unreasonable service charge?
No. The Upper Tribunal said that neither consultation nor dispensation could enable the landlord to recover the charges. Reasonableness is a separate test.
Who was the expert in the case?
The leaseholders' expert is not named in the Upper Tribunal's decision. His evidence was that much of the work was unnecessary or superfluous and that the specification was poor.
What is the difference between a witness of fact and an expert witness?
A witness of fact describes what they saw or did. An expert gives independent opinion within their field and owes an overriding duty to the tribunal. A director of the landlord company can give factual evidence but is not an independent expert.
Do I need a surveyor to challenge major works?
It is not compulsory, but disputes about scope, necessity and cost are technical. An independent chartered building surveyor's report is often the most persuasive evidence available.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Take specific advice on your own circumstances.
References