Three surveyors inspected the same hangar roof. None of them saw water coming in, and all of them agreed the roof was at or past the end of its life. One priced temporary repairs at £128,000. Another put them at between £512,000 and £1.2 million. The occupier asking the court to order those repairs left with nothing. For any expert witness surveyor asked to support a roof repair injunction, AirX Jet Support Ltd v London Jet Centre (Stanstead) Ltd (2026) EWHC 2558 (BP) is a careful study in what expert evidence must do, and what happens when it answers a slightly different question from the one the judge needs answered [1].
His Honour Judge Richard Carter, sitting as a Judge of the High Court, heard the application on 23 July 2026 and gave judgment on 8 October 2026 [1].
Key Takeaways
- The court refused an interim mandatory injunction requiring a landlord-side company to repair a leaking hangar roof.
- Expert reports had been ordered specifically so the court could understand the roof's current state. They did not settle it.
- The experts were never asked to comment on later photographs and videos of leaks, so the reports did not help on the key factual dispute.
- A cost estimate of about £18,250 at the first hearing had grown to a range of £128,000 to £1.2 million, which changed the court's whole assessment.
- Instructions to experts need to track the legal test, and need updating when new evidence arrives.
The dispute
The claimants run a private jet airline and charter business from the east half of the Diamond Hangar at Stansted Airport. They say the defendants must keep the roof in repair and supply heating, and that the roof leaks on to aircraft, equipment and offices. The defendants admit only an implied term that the premises be reasonably fit for purpose [1].
In April 2025 the claimants applied for an interim mandatory injunction, an order made before trial that requires a party to do something, here to repair the roof. Andrew de Mestre KC, sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge, gave judgment on that application on 14 October 2025. He found there was a serious issue to be tried, but said he did not have a clear and up-to-date picture of the roof. He adjourned the roof application and directed expert evidence and a joint statement [1].
What the experts said
The expert evidence before Judge Carter was this:
- Mr Hopkinson, for the claimants (report dated 2 February 2026): temporary works costing £512,000 to £1.2 million, which might prove effective for 12 to 18 months.
- Mr Lehmann, for the defendants (report dated 10 March 2026): temporary works costing £128,000, lasting 3 to 4 years.
- Joint report (8 July 2026): the cost and scope of temporary works were not agreed.
An earlier report for the defendants, dated 3 February 2026, was described in the judgment as disavowed [1].
There was a good deal of agreement. The roof is a mechanically fixed single-ply membrane dating from about 1989. At about 37 years old it has outlived an expected life of 25 to 35 years. A liquid-applied system was the right form of temporary repair [1].
The disagreement was about the present. The claimants' expert said it was not possible to state with certainty whether the roof was or was not currently weatherproof. He regarded it as beyond economic repair and recommended full replacement. The defendants' expert said the roof was currently watertight, because he had seen nothing to suggest otherwise [1].
Why the expert witness surveyor evidence did not decide the roof repair injunction
Three problems emerge from the judgment.
1. The reports did not engage with the leak evidence. After the inspections, both sides produced photographs and videos said to show, or not show, water coming in. The experts were not asked to comment on them. The judge said in terms that the expert reports did not assist him on that question, and that neither expert had confirmed the roof was not watertight [1].
2. The cost evidence undermined the application. At the first hearing, an earlier expert for the claimants had put the cost of repairs in the region of £18,250. An order to carry out works at that price is one thing. By July 2026 the claimants' own expert was pricing temporary works at up to £1.2 million. Judge Carter held that the earlier conclusion that damages would not be an adequate remedy no longer held, because it had rested on an unrealistic estimate of the cost of complying with the order [1].
3. The claimants' expert would not stand behind the works sought. He recommended replacement and disclaimed responsibility for temporary repairs. That is an honest professional position. It is also difficult ground from which to ask a court to order temporary repairs.
Set against that, the claimed losses were modest. On the evidence they might reach about £250,000 over two years, and water damage itself possibly only about £10,000. Leaks were running at roughly eight incidents in nine months [1].
The decision
The court applied the familiar American Cyanamid approach, with the added caution that applies to mandatory orders before trial: the court wants a high degree of assurance that the claimant will succeed at trial.
The judge accepted there was a serious issue to be tried. But works costing somewhere between half a million and £1.2 million, which would not prevent a catastrophic failure and could not be shown to be needed now, did not meet the test. An implied term that premises be fit for purpose is not the same thing as a full repairing covenant. The application was dismissed [1].
Lessons for surveyors acting as experts
- Read the order, then read the legal test. The directions asked whether the roof was weatherproof and watertight and, if not, what temporary repairs would last until trial. An expert's answer of "it cannot be said either way" may be accurate, but it leaves the party who bears the burden without the finding they need.
- Ask for the later evidence. Under Practice Direction 35 an expert should say when a question cannot be answered without more information [2]. If leaks are being filmed after the inspection, the expert should see the footage and say what it shows.
- Inspect in the right conditions. A dry-day inspection of a roof that leaks in heavy rain proves little. Water testing, thermal imaging or a return visit in bad weather should be considered and, if not done, the report should say why.
- Price what is being asked for. If the application is for temporary works, the costing should be for a scheme the expert would be prepared to specify.
- Use the joint statement properly. Narrowing the issues is the purpose. Here the joint report agreed the history and the materials, and left open the one thing the court most needed.
Lessons for landlords, tenants and occupiers
- Be clear about the repairing obligation before a dispute arises. Much of this case turns on the absence of an agreed, written repairing covenant.
- Keep a dated log of every leak, with photographs, weather conditions and what was damaged.
- An early, low estimate can win the first hearing and lose the second. Get a realistic costing from the start.
- For an ageing roof, a planned condition survey is cheaper than litigation about whether it is leaking today.
Conclusion
The roof at the Diamond Hangar is old, and everyone agreed on that. What the court needed to know was narrower: is it letting water in now, and what would a proportionate fix cost? The expert evidence did not answer the first question and gave answers almost ten times apart on the second. The claim itself continues to trial, where those questions will be looked at again.
Anyone preparing a disrepair claim, or defending one, should brief their surveyor on the precise questions the court will ask, share new evidence as it arrives, and check the draft report against the order before it is served.
References
[1] AirX Jet Support Ltd and another v London Jet Centre (Stanstead) Ltd and another (2026) EWHC 2558 (BP), judgment of 8 October 2026, Find Case Law, The National Archives: caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk
[2] Practice Direction 35: Experts and Assessors, Ministry of Justice: justice.gov.uk